Being Wanted

The one argument coming from the pro-abortion crowd that repels me deeply is the one that says human life is valuable based on whether it’s wanted or not. When you grow up as the awkward, bullied reject, you understand deeply how much your presence is unwanted by the people around you. You can’t help but to exist, and on some level, you might believe that God wants you or you wouldn’t be here. But there is the sense that, given an amoral and lawless society, you would be deemed expendable and taken out.

I’ve heard it numerous times from the mouths of pro-abortion activists; when asked what the difference is between a human baby and a fetus that can be flushed or ripped violently from the womb, the answer is when the mother wants it, it’s a baby who needs protection. Otherwise, it’s a clump of cells with no personhood rights. These are virtually direct quotes from any number of abortion supporters.

I’ve discussed before that we humans are not logical creatures. This is, to be honest, the way God created us. He created us to be primarily emotional and instinctive; that is our first response to any given situation. Our instincts are intriguing, as they can be very basic, as in, I’m starving; I must have instant sugar, and they can conversely be very complex, instant decisions made based off years of inputs that work together in the background to aid us in this process. Logic is a secondary, learned skill, but it is solipsistic, processed through our filters. The conclusions are only as good as the premises, as well, so it’s possible to have flawless logic and still be completely wrong.

Most people have not learned logic and don’t understand cause and effect very deeply, especially when they want or don’t want something very badly. I don’t think I need to explain why the concept of only wanted people should be allowed personhood status will have a very bad logical outcome. But it’s going to be difficult to get around the initial instinct and emotional drive of a human that simply wants to escape consequences. They won’t understand the logic. They will turn it into a moralistic argument about the bad ethics of forcing a woman to go through an unwanted pregnancy. This is, of course, a false input, but most won’t perceive why. Even professors, who are supposed to be above-average, will refuse to accept that their conclusions are wrong.

You might recognize that I have an emotional response to the argument that only wanted people have value. Yes, it does make me emotional. Very emotional. My life experiences have taught me on an emotional level to be sensitive to the maltreatment of underdogs whom nobody likes. We know what happens when we devalue certain people; history has left humanity with those emotional wounds. And if you consider that a pre born child isn’t unwanted for any particular reason, it’s even more emotionally devastating. I was and am a scrawny, awkward person. It’s easy to dislike me. I’m obnoxious. But a mother who doesn’t have any personal grudges against a tiny being who has done nothing offensive because they haven’t had the chance to yet…just tears me up inside. It’s so cold. It’s so wrong, like the neighborhood boy who unaccountably pulls the wings off insects. He can; that’s the only reason. Well, she can, too, except those aren’t wings she’s ripping off a fly. They are the arms and legs of her own child.

This battle will never be won by pitting logic against emotions, anyway. What it really comes down is spiritual oppression. That is why you often find pro-abort protestors screaming obscenities and hail Satan. They do this ostensibly to rattle Christians, but it rather becomes an outpouring of their souls. These people are not emotional wrecks; they are spiritual wrecks.

Therefore, praying and preaching the gospel are the only answers. Too simple? I don’t care. My state’s a mess, with some of the most liberal abortion laws in the world. It is overwhelming to live here sometimes. What can I do? Sign a few petitions? Carry banners? Jesus is better. He is always the answer.

6 thoughts on “Being Wanted”

  1. Oh ouch, this is a painful post, Jill. You are absolutely right, the worth and value of a person has absolutely nothing to do with whether or not he or she is wanted. That mindset is the ultimate solipsism, the very definition of narcissism, people can only exist as extensions of me, as commodities, as what they will bring to my equation.

    That is absolutely devastating to a child, it creates deep wounds. Kids are designed to be sacrificially loved, to learn to trust that they have innate worth and value because that has been clearly demonstrated to them.

    I’ve been really blessed and healed by studying Mary, LOL, which you can’t repeat too loudly in protestant circles! Just the same, she is the antidote, the precise opposite of self serving narcissism. She is the epitome of what sacrificial mother love is supposed to look like. Some of us need to sit beside her for a while because we never got that ourselves and we desperately need some re-mothering.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Mary is the ultimate mother love. Protestants don’t understand why Catholics love her. She’s a corrective to so much bad in the world. But I get the idea some Protestants just hate women, so they want her to be worthless. I’ve heard that from the mouths of Protestants. “She’s worthless.” “She’s nothing special.” I heard a Protestant pastor call her “garbage” once. Like, do we have to swing all the way to hate to prove we’re not worshipping her?

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I’ll stretch this out a little bit. You are on the right track with your thoughts on logic, because pro-life and pro-choice (I don’t label it “pro-abortion”) beliefs are based entirely on conviction. Conviction isn’t based on reason and evidence because it’s always upstream from the logical process; we “logic” our convictions after the fact. This is especially true when talking about the beginnings of human life, because there’s no good analogies to relate arguments in a discussion. A fetus’ personhood is a matter of conviction. I believe a fetus is a person, just because–it’s my conviction, which doesn’t require justification. Sure, there’s evidence to go along with the conviction, but if I were pro-choice, that evidence doesn’t weigh as much as other evidence, because it’s backed by a different conviction.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, that is sadly true. It’s nearly impossible to get past a person’s personal convictions. The only people I know who flip sides do so because they experience something that flips their emotional buttons. For example, they see little torn apart body parts. In the other direction, I know someone who flipped the other way when her friend decided it was wrong to abort and then came unglued because of the stress of caring for a severely disabled child.

      Like

Leave a reply to insanitybytes22 Cancel reply